The Yume NIkki fanbase isn't much better so idunno what you're trying to say
I request rule 34 on this!
The manga is ok, but it can't capture the dreamlike atmosphere as well as the game, which was the whole point of the game in the first place.
The weird sound effects, the surreal music, the sense of dread when toringen are chasing after you, is something the manga can't reproduce. YN is one of those games that doesn't translate well into other mediums.
Also the whole game was made vague so that you kind of make up the story yourself.
I actually really like the manga. For what it is (it being giving a plot to a game with absolutely no plot whatsoever), it's pretty good. I like that they gave Madotsuki a bit of a personality, as well.
To those of you saying, "BUT ITS NOT LIKE THE GAME" or "ITS TOO MUCH LIKE THE GAME", how about you grow a pair and make a manga yourself? There's no solid story or character there, so the writer has to come up with one on their own. If they didn't, then it wouldn't be a manga. It'd be a picture-book.
To be fair, you can't really incorporate a dream-like atmosphere into a manga. You can't make a manga be like the game, because in a manga there is ALWAYS a story. If a manga didn't have a story and was "up for debate" the way the game is, then it wouldn't be entertaining. It'd just be a bunch of fan-art strung together in a book.