I didn't like Lily's route because most of the route didn't present much of a challenge to Hisao. Lily just sort of fell into his arms. The only suspense was at the end.
Emi's route was the most challenging story-wise and had the biggest bumps in the road. It also had a well written ending.
I liked the ending for Hanako's route but overall it was ok.
Rin just pissed me off. :<
Shizune's route had the best intro video, and I loved how the communication issues were worked into the story.
Shizune = Emi > Hanako > Lily = Rin
I haven't actually played through Hanako's bad ending. I usually don't go for bad endings intentionally. But the good ending sucked major ass
It was basically:"Hey I kinda raped you but I sorta didn't""lol k"~The End~
I majorly enjoyed Hanako's route ( the good one ), It was the first one I went through and I loved the ending. It was just perfect. I played through everyone else's except lilly's route, and I absolutely hated Rin's route. Its like they were just trying to give you that "this girl is too fucked up for me" feeling.
Hanako = Emi > Shizune > Rin
I don't put lilly in because im not finished with hers
Lily's route made me cry alot. the others… eh, shit happens hisao. but Lily's… *bawls eyes out when she leaves*