What kind of character sprites do you prefer to see in fangames? Do you like to see new character sprites, or do you prefer the commonplace Madotsuki sprite edits?As long as the Madotsuki sprite edits are relatively nice, I usually favor those over new

Name
Email
Subject	Spoiler Image
Comment
File
Password	(For file deletion.)

File: 1441573526633.png (19.15 KB, 122x56, Untitled-2.png)

Anonymous 09/06/15 (Sun) 21:05:26 No.10955

What kind of character sprites do you prefer to see in fangames? Do you like to see new character sprites, or do you prefer the commonplace Madotsuki sprite edits?

As long as the Madotsuki sprite edits are relatively nice, I usually favor those over new sprites.

Owl 09/06/15 (Sun) 21:39:37 No.10956

I favor new sprites, as long as they are relatively well made. If nothing else, it shows that some effort was put into the game right away, making me less likely to blow it off as another clone of a clone of a clone of a clone of a clone…

Anonymous 09/06/15 (Sun) 21:50:17 No.10957

File: 1441576217847.png (186.54 KB, 540x306, lookatyourface.png)

>commonplace Madotsuki sprite edits
Aka recolors, fuck that shit, it's not the fact that they are recolors, it just gives the impression of playing another fongom clone.

I have played lots of fangames for long time already and now I kinda beg for different things, even in those minor details, let's get real most fangames are literally the same thing.

A mado edit doesn't mean a game is bad or unoriginal, it's just a "ew" first impression to me.

Anonymous 09/07/15 (Mon) 01:19:33 No.10958

My preference goes something like this:

Completely original sprite > Mado edit > RPG Maker default sprite

Anonymous 09/07/15 (Mon) 01:31:20 No.10959

File: 1441589480176.jpg (42.87 KB, 512x344, TiZiwOE.jpg)

>>10957
same here

Anonymous 09/17/15 (Thu) 12:09:56 No.10982

File: 1442491796658.png (19.36 KB, 137x114, yuppo.png)

I actually think Mado recolors are quite charming in fangames. Of course, it is fun to see original sprites, yes, but I do enjoy seeing what others can pull off with a basic Mado-type sprite.

Though, that's just my opinion!

Cat Glitter 12/31/15 (Thu) 11:29:39 No.11224

I prefer Mado edits.
It feels more like a proper continuation f the game universe. I mean yeah, new sprites are nice but the original style is my favorite